Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
Miami Probate & Real Estate Litigation Lawyer
Hablamos Español
Schedule A Free Consultation
305-607-7011
Miami Probate & Real Estate Litigation Lawyer / Fort Lauderdale Tenants in Common Disputes Lawyer

Fort Lauderdale Tenants in Common Disputes Lawyer

Co-owning property sounds straightforward until it isn’t. When two or more people hold title to real estate as tenants in common, each owner brings their own financial interests, family circumstances, and long-term plans to the table. Those interests don’t always align, and when they diverge, the property itself becomes a source of serious conflict. Fort Lauderdale tenants in common disputes arise in situations ranging from inherited family homes to jointly purchased investment properties, and resolving them requires both a command of Florida property law and the willingness to advocate firmly for one owner’s rights against another’s.

Broward County’s real estate market, one of the most active in South Florida, creates constant opportunities for co-ownership conflicts to surface. An oceanfront condo purchased by siblings after a parent’s death. A rental property bought by business partners who later fall out. A home acquired by an unmarried couple who eventually separate. Each of these scenarios produces a different legal dispute, but they all share the same underlying tension: multiple people with legal rights to the same piece of property who cannot agree on what to do with it.

At Valero Law, attorney David Valero represents property owners throughout Fort Lauderdale and Broward County in disputes that arise from tenants in common arrangements. The firm handles everything from contested partition actions to disputes over improper transfers, unequal contributions, and co-owner conduct that damages the shared asset. Whether you are the co-owner being squeezed out or the one seeking to exit an arrangement that no longer works, having a Fort Lauderdale real estate litigation attorney who understands both property law and courtroom strategy makes a decisive difference.

What Tenants in Common Disputes Actually Look Like in Broward County

A tenancy in common is a form of property ownership in which two or more people each hold an undivided fractional interest in the same piece of real estate. Unlike joint tenancy, there is no right of survivorship, meaning an owner’s interest passes through their estate rather than automatically to the surviving co-owners. That distinction matters enormously in Florida, particularly when a co-owner dies and their share transfers to heirs who had no relationship with, and possibly no interest in working with, the remaining owners.

Disputes between tenants in common tend to cluster around a few recurring fault lines. One co-owner wants to sell; the other refuses. One party has been collecting rent without sharing it. Someone made improvements to the property and now demands reimbursement. A co-owner’s interest passed through their estate to multiple heirs who can’t agree among themselves, let alone with the surviving original owner. A deed was executed under questionable circumstances, and someone is challenging whether the tenancy in common was validly created to begin with.

Broward County courts handle these disputes regularly. The Seventeenth Judicial Circuit, which covers Broward County, has seen a sustained volume of partition and property dispute cases driven by the region’s high property values and the frequency of inherited real estate situations that arise when longtime South Florida residents pass away. Fort Lauderdale’s diverse property landscape, ranging from waterfront estates and luxury condominiums to multi-family rental properties and commercial parcels, means that tenants in common disputes here often involve substantial sums and multiple competing legal claims that don’t resolve easily without litigation.

Common Issues in Fort Lauderdale Tenants in Common Cases

  • Partition actions: When co-owners cannot agree on whether to sell or how to divide the property, a partition action forces a resolution through the courts. Florida law generally allows any tenant in common to petition for partition, and courts typically either order the property sold with proceeds divided according to each owner’s interest, or in rare cases involving land that can be physically divided, order a partition in kind.
  • Disputes over rental income and expenses: When a co-owned property generates rental income, Florida law requires that income be shared proportionally. A co-owner who collects all the rent while excluding others from the economic benefit of the property can face an accounting claim and liability for the unpaid share.
  • Ouster and exclusion claims: If one co-owner physically excludes another from accessing the property, that constitutes an ouster under Florida law. An ousted co-owner may be entitled to a fair rental value for the period of exclusion, not just their proportional share going forward.
  • Contribution disputes over improvements and carrying costs: One co-owner who pays mortgage obligations, property taxes, insurance, or the cost of necessary repairs may be entitled to seek contribution from other co-owners. However, voluntary improvements, as opposed to necessary maintenance, generally do not create the same right of reimbursement.
  • Contested transfers and deed disputes: A tenancy in common interest can be transferred by deed, sold, or inherited. Disputes arise when a transfer is alleged to have been fraudulent, forged, made under undue influence, or executed without the transferor’s capacity. These claims often overlap with probate matters when the transfer occurred near the time of death.
  • Valuation disagreements in forced sale proceedings: When a court orders a partition by sale, determining the fair market value of the property, particularly in Fort Lauderdale’s fluctuating real estate market, becomes its own contested issue. Co-owners frequently dispute appraisals, the timing of the sale, and which costs should be deducted before proceeds are distributed.
  • Inherited co-ownership disputes involving estates: When a property owner dies leaving real estate to multiple beneficiaries as tenants in common, the resulting ownership arrangement can involve heirs who have never communicated with each other. These disputes sit at the intersection of probate and property law, requiring an attorney who handles both areas.

How to Protect Your Position When a Co-Ownership Dispute Arises

The first practical step after a tenants in common dispute emerges is to gather documentation of your ownership interest and the history of the property. That means locating the deed that reflects your fractional interest, any written agreements made between co-owners at the time of purchase, records of payments you have made toward the mortgage, taxes, insurance, or repairs, and any communications with the other co-owners about the property’s management or future. In the absence of a written co-ownership agreement, courts rely heavily on the deed language and financial records to determine each party’s rights.

Fort Lauderdale tenants in common matters are handled in the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit Court of Florida, located in the Broward County Courthouse at 201 SE 6th Street in downtown Fort Lauderdale. Partition actions are filed there as civil cases, and depending on the complexity of the dispute, they may involve discovery, expert appraisals, and hearings before a circuit court judge. A partition action can also be filed in a simplified process in some circumstances, but disputes over contribution, ouster, and fraud generally require more involved litigation.

One of the most consequential mistakes co-owners make is waiting too long to document their contributions to the property. If you have been paying the mortgage, handling repairs, or managing tenants without any formal record, your ability to recover those costs from co-owners depends on your ability to prove them. Bank records, receipts, and written communications become essential evidence. Another common mistake is attempting to negotiate directly with a co-owner without understanding the legal positions each side actually holds. Co-owners who believe they can simply refuse to agree to a sale indefinitely often don’t account for the fact that any co-owner can force a sale through a partition action, regardless of the others’ objections.

Florida’s statutes of limitations apply to contribution claims and accounting claims between co-owners. These deadlines vary depending on the nature of the claim. Waiting too long to assert your rights can eliminate them, regardless of how strong your underlying position might be. Consulting a Fort Lauderdale tenants in common attorney promptly after a dispute surfaces is the most effective way to understand which claims you need to preserve and how.

When Partition Is the Only Path Forward

Florida law treats partition as a matter of right for any co-owner who holds a legal interest in the property. Courts do not require you to prove wrongdoing or bad faith on the other co-owner’s part; the mere fact that you hold an undivided interest and cannot reach agreement with your co-owners about the property’s future is sufficient to support a partition claim. This makes partition one of the most powerful legal tools available to a tenant in common who wants out of a co-ownership arrangement.

The practical mechanics of partition in Broward County involve filing a civil complaint, naming all co-owners as parties, and asking the court to order either a physical division or a sale of the property. Because most Fort Lauderdale properties, particularly condominium units, waterfront homes, and commercial properties, cannot be physically divided in a way that preserves their value, courts overwhelmingly order partition by sale. The property is appraised, listed, sold, and the proceeds are divided after accounting for any adjustments based on contribution claims or credits one party is owed over another.

Co-owners who owe credits to one another because of unequal contributions, unjust enrichment, or other equitable claims see those issues resolved as part of the partition proceeding itself. This means a well-prepared partition case doesn’t just end the co-ownership; it also addresses the accumulated financial disputes that built up during the period of shared ownership. A Fort Lauderdale real estate litigation attorney at Valero Law can assess which credits and offsets apply to your situation and build the documentation necessary to support them in court.

Why Valero Law for Fort Lauderdale Tenants in Common Litigation

Valero Law represents clients in real estate and property disputes throughout South Florida with the kind of direct, attentive representation that genuinely changes outcomes. Attorney David Valero handles real estate litigation, probate matters, and business disputes, and many of the most complex tenants in common cases require all three areas of knowledge working together. When a co-ownership dispute stems from an estate, involves a fraudulent deed, or requires untangling a business relationship that included jointly held property, depth across these areas matters.

Clients who work with David Valero reach him directly. There are no layers of staff between a client and the attorney handling their matter. That responsiveness is especially important in property disputes, where a co-owner’s unilateral action, such as listing the property for sale without your consent, entering into a lease agreement, or taking out debt against the property, can damage your position quickly if not addressed. The firm handles both the negotiation phase and the litigation that follows when negotiation fails, and its approach is built around honest assessments of where a client actually stands rather than managing expectations downward after the fact.

Valero Law serves clients across Miami-Dade County and South Florida, including Broward County matters involving Fort Lauderdale and the surrounding communities. The firm’s cross-disciplinary experience with real estate litigation, probate disputes, and business litigation makes it well-positioned for the type of multi-layered tenants in common conflicts that arise most often in this market.

Questions People Ask About Tenants in Common Disputes in Fort Lauderdale

Can one tenant in common force a sale of the property without the other owner’s consent?

Yes. Under Florida law, any co-owner holding an interest in real property as a tenant in common may file a partition action to compel a sale of the property. The other co-owners cannot veto this right simply by refusing to cooperate. If the court determines a physical division of the property is not practical, which is almost always the case for residential and commercial properties in Fort Lauderdale, it will order the property sold and the proceeds distributed according to each owner’s legal interest.

What happens to a tenant in common’s share when that owner dies?

Unlike joint tenancy, a tenancy in common does not include a right of survivorship. When a tenant in common dies, their fractional interest passes through their estate according to their will, or through Florida’s intestate succession laws if they had no will. That share may go to a surviving spouse, children, or other heirs who then become new co-owners alongside the original surviving owners. This is one of the most common ways tenants in common disputes are triggered, particularly when heirs are strangers to each other or have conflicting plans for the property.

Is there a difference between a tenancy in common and a joint tenancy in Florida?

Yes, and the distinction is legally significant. Joint tenancy includes a right of survivorship, meaning a deceased co-owner’s interest passes automatically to the surviving joint tenants rather than through probate. Tenancy in common does not include this feature. Florida law requires specific language in a deed to create a joint tenancy with right of survivorship; without that language, a deed conveying property to two or more people generally creates a tenancy in common by default.

What can I do if my co-owner is collecting rental income and not sharing it with me?

A co-owner who collects rental income from a property held in tenancy in common is generally obligated to share that income proportionally with the other owners. If your co-owner has been pocketing rent without distributing your share, you may have a claim for an accounting and for the unpaid amounts going back to when the exclusion began. Courts can order restitution of these amounts and factor them into the partition proceeding if the dispute ultimately goes that route.

How does a partition action affect a property that has a mortgage on it?

A mortgage against the property does not prevent a partition action from proceeding. When the property is sold through the partition process, the proceeds are first used to satisfy any outstanding liens, including the mortgage, before the remaining net proceeds are divided among the co-owners. If one co-owner has been making all the mortgage payments while the other has not, that co-owner may be entitled to a credit for the disproportionate payments made, which would be resolved as part of the partition proceeding.

Can a tenant in common transfer their interest to someone else without the other owners’ approval?

Generally, yes. A tenant in common may sell, gift, or devise their fractional interest without the consent of the other co-owners. This means a co-owner could sell their interest to a stranger, a creditor, or an investor who then becomes your new co-owner with no prior relationship with you. The remaining original co-owners typically have no right of first refusal unless a written agreement between the parties specifically grants one.

What happens when co-owners disagree about whether to rent or sell a property they jointly own?

Without a written agreement establishing decision-making procedures, disagreements about managing a jointly owned property have limited informal remedies. One co-owner cannot generally bind the other to a lease without consent, though they can occupy the property themselves. When the deadlock becomes unworkable, the most direct legal resolution is a partition action, which removes the co-ownership structure entirely by forcing a sale and distributing proceeds.

If I paid for repairs or improvements on the property, can I recover those costs from my co-owner?

It depends on the nature of the expenditures. Costs for necessary repairs and maintenance, such as a failing roof or structural issues, may give rise to a contribution claim against co-owners who did not share those costs. Voluntary upgrades or improvements made without the other owner’s agreement are treated differently; courts generally do not require co-owners to reimburse each other for improvements that one party made unilaterally for their own benefit. Keeping detailed records of all expenditures is essential to pursuing either type of claim.

Can a tenants in common dispute be resolved without going to court?

Yes. Many of these disputes are resolved through negotiated buyouts, written co-ownership agreements, or mediation before a lawsuit is filed. One co-owner may agree to purchase the other’s interest at an agreed-upon price, effectively ending the co-ownership without court involvement. Mediation can also be productive when co-owners have a relationship worth preserving. However, when one party refuses to engage in good faith or is actively damaging the property or withholding income, litigation becomes the necessary tool for resolution.

Does it matter if the tenancy in common was created through inheritance versus a voluntary purchase?

The source of the co-ownership affects the context and sometimes the claims available, but not the fundamental legal rights each tenant in common holds. Co-owners who inherited their interests have the same right to partition as those who purchased together. What changes is the surrounding factual picture: inherited co-ownerships often involve probate court matters that run alongside the property dispute, estate assets that were transferred under questionable circumstances, and family dynamics that complicate negotiation. An attorney who handles both probate litigation and real estate disputes is better positioned to address those overlapping layers.

How long does a partition action typically take in Broward County?

The timeline varies considerably depending on whether the co-owners dispute the right to partition itself, argue over contribution credits, or contest the property’s valuation. An uncontested partition where the parties agree on the property’s value and have no outstanding financial disputes between them can move relatively quickly once filed. Contested partition actions involving disputed credits, appraisal disagreements, or fraud claims can take considerably longer given the discovery process and hearing schedules in Broward County’s circuit courts. Beginning the process early, rather than waiting for the dispute to worsen, generally produces better outcomes.

Serving Tenants in Common Dispute Clients Throughout Broward County and Beyond

Valero Law represents clients in Fort Lauderdale and across Broward County, including homeowners and investors in Pompano Beach, Deerfield Beach, Boca Raton, Coral Springs, Margate, Coconut Creek, Tamarac, Lauderhill, Lauderdale Lakes, North Lauderdale, Oakland Park, Wilton Manors, Dania Beach, Hollywood, Hallandale Beach, Pembroke Pines, Miramar, and Davie. The firm also serves clients in the coastal communities of Lighthouse Point, Hillsboro Beach, and Sea Ranch Lakes, as well as the western Broward communities of Weston, Cooper City, and Southwest Ranches. For property disputes that straddle the Broward and Miami-Dade county lines, or for clients whose co-owned property is located in Miami-Dade while they reside in Broward, the firm’s presence across South Florida allows for consistent representation throughout the dispute.

Tenants in common disputes often involve properties in highly specific Fort Lauderdale locations: Las Olas beachfront condominiums, Victoria Park single-family homes, Colee Hammock estates, and commercial properties along Federal Highway or Andrews Avenue. The legal issues these properties generate are the same whether the property is a modest duplex or a multi-million-dollar waterfront asset, and the firm represents clients across that full spectrum.

Fort Lauderdale Tenants in Common Attorney Ready to Help

A co-ownership dispute that sits unresolved doesn’t stay the same over time; it tends to get more complicated as circumstances change, as other co-owners take actions that affect the property, and as financial stakes shift with the market. Speaking with a Fort Lauderdale tenants in common attorney early in the process gives you a clear picture of your legal position, your available remedies, and the realistic path to resolution before the situation deteriorates further.

At Valero Law, David Valero handles these matters directly, communicates quickly, and gives clients honest guidance about what their situation actually requires. If you are dealing with a co-ownership conflict over Fort Lauderdale or Broward County real estate, call Valero Law to schedule a free confidential consultation and discuss what your options look like from a legal standpoint.

Schedule Your Free Consultation
* Required Field

By submitting this form I acknowledge that contacting Valero Law through this website does not create an attorney-client relationship, and any information I send is not protected by attorney-client privilege.

protected by reCAPTCHA Privacy - Terms