Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
Miami Probate & Real Estate Litigation Lawyer
Hablamos Español
Schedule A Free Consultation
305-607-7011
Miami Probate & Real Estate Litigation Lawyer / Blog / Appellate / Why Your Appeal Might Fail and How To Strengthen It

Why Your Appeal Might Fail and How To Strengthen It

__Appeals

If you lost your case at trial and you believe the judge got it all wrong, it can be incredibly frustrating. But that’s why appeals exist. However, while an appeal can help you get a second look, it’s not another trial. There are specific rules that govern appeals in Florida, and not every error justifies a reversal. If you are considering an appeal, understanding why cases fail can help you identify stronger arguments and avoid mistakes that could make your appeal unsuccessful.

1.    The Argument Is Not Supported by the Trial Record

The appellate court reviews what happened in the lower court through the record. This includes transcripts, admitted evidence, motions and court orders. New witnesses are not heard, nor is evidence that was not presented at trial. Therefore, if your argument depends on facts that are missing from the record, proving the alleged error can become difficult. This is why ensuring the trial record accurately reflects the proceedings is important.

2.    The Trial Court Gets the Benefit of Certain Doubts

Generally, appellate courts do not review every decision from scratch. The standard of review depends on the issue being challenged. Legal questions may get de novo review, while factual findings usually receive greater deference. For example, if a jury believed one witness over another, the court of appeals will not consider that credibility decision just because you disagree with it. You must demonstrate an error that the applicable standard of review allows the court to correct.

3.    The Issue Was Not Properly Preserved

In most cases, a lawyer must object or make the appropriate argument during trial to preserve the issue for appeal. It also gives the trial judge an opportunity to address the issue before the case proceeds further. Now, if no timely objection was made, the court may decline to consider the problem. However, there are some exceptions, such as with claims involving fundamental error.

4.    The Error Did Not Affect the Outcome

Under Florida’s harmless error rule, an error must have been sufficiently harmful to necessitate a new proceeding or a similar appellate relief. For instance, say the court improperly admitted some evidence, but the remaining evidence supports the judgment. In such a case, if the error didn’t meet the applicable threshold for reversal, the appeal may fail, even if a mistake was made.

How Can You Strengthen Your Appeal?

There are several ways you can strengthen your appeal.

1.    Get an Appellate Lawyer Involved Early

An appellate lawyer can review the judgement, motions, transcripts and filings to identify potential errors. Early legal guidance can also help ensure you do not miss the deadlines and identify issues that may need to be preserved before the trial concludes.

2.    Build Your Argument Around a Reversible Error

An appeal requires showing more than just the fact that the result was unfair. As such, it’s best to focus on a specific legal error, the applicable standard of review, and how that error affected the proceedings or judgment.

Contact Us for Legal Help

If you believe a Florida court made a significant error in your case, contact our Miami civil appeals lawyer today at Valero Law by calling 305-607-7011. We can help you understand your options and decide whether pursuing an appeal makes sense. We serve clients in Davie, Coconut Grove, Broward County, and Miami-Dade County.

Schedule Your Free Consultation
* Required Field

By submitting this form I acknowledge that contacting Valero Law through this website does not create an attorney-client relationship, and any information I send is not protected by attorney-client privilege.

protected by reCAPTCHA Privacy - Terms