Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
Miami Probate & Real Estate Litigation Lawyer
Hablamos Español
Schedule A Free Consultation
305-607-7011
Miami Probate & Real Estate Litigation Lawyer / Blog / Civil Appeals / What Business Owners Should Know About Appealing a Contract Dispute Judgment

What Business Owners Should Know About Appealing a Contract Dispute Judgment

BusinessLit3

Contracts keep business relationships on track by stating what must be done, when and the exact terms. When one party fails to deliver, misses a payment or breaks an agreed timeline, the dispute can end up in court. But what happens when the judge rules against you? For Florida business owners, an unfavorable judgement does not necessarily end the matter. You may be able to appeal the ruling. However, success depends on a few key things, as we discuss in this article.

What Is the Standard of Review in a Contract Appeal?

The standard of review refers to the legal lens an appellate court uses to examine a trial court’s decision. It determines how closely the appeals court examines the ruling and how much weight it gives the trial judge’s findings. The standard applied matters because an appeal is not a second trial. You cannot present the same or different evidence and ask the judge to reach a different conclusion.

How Are Business Contract Disputes Reviewed in Florida?

Appellate courts apply four main standards:

  • De novo review
  • Abuse of discretion
  • Competent substantial evidence
  • Departure from essential requirements of law

The applicable standard depends on the issue you are challenging. However, when a dispute is about an unambiguous contract, Florida appellate courts generally apply de novo review. This means they consider the legal question independently without deferring to the trial court’s interpretation,

For example, say a trial judge interprets a payment clause in a commercial agreement in a way that conflicts with its clear wording. In that case, an appeal may allow you to challenge that legal interpretation. However, disagreements about what actually happened are different. If the dispute is, for instance, whether goods or services were delivered, payments were made, or an agreement was modified, the trial court’s factual findings receive greater deference. Therefore, those findings may be reviewed for competent substantial evidence.

Then, there are other decisions, such as evidentiary rulings or procedural rulings. These may be reviewed for an abuse of discretion. To get a ruling reversed, you need to show more than simply that the appellate court might have decided the issue differently.

How Does the Standard of Review Affect Your Appeal Strategy?

Understanding the applicable standard can help you identify which arguments have a realistic chance of success.

For example, if the judge misinterpreted the contract, the appeal may focus on the agreement’s language and the applicable law. If it’s about factual findings, you must demonstrate why the record doesn’t support those findings under the applicable standard.

In your appellate brief, you need to connect the alleged error to the relevant legal test. You also need to consider whether the issue was properly reserved during the original proceedings. Some errors must be raised at trial to be available for appellate review.

You should also consider whether appealing a contract judgment is worth it. Before appealing, consider factors such as legal fees, the amount at stake, collection prospects and deadlines.

We Are Here To Help

If your business has received an unfair contract judgement in Florida, contact our Miami civil appeals lawyer today at Valero

Law by calling 305-607-7011. Our attorneys can review the order and help you decide whether an appeal is worthwhile and legally supportable. We serve clients in Davie, Coconut Grove, Broward County, and Miami-Dade County.

Schedule Your Free Consultation
* Required Field

By submitting this form I acknowledge that contacting Valero Law through this website does not create an attorney-client relationship, and any information I send is not protected by attorney-client privilege.

protected by reCAPTCHA Privacy - Terms